Is water pooling under the tank, or is there a smell of gas?
If you smell gas near the water heater, leave the house first and leave the door open behind you. Do not flip light switches, unplug anything or go looking for the leak. Once you are outside, call your gas supplier's emergency line. They make the gas supply safe, and the plumbing work comes after that.
Water around the base is the more common problem, and it is usually easier to contain than it looks. Turn the cold water valve on the pipe above the tank clockwise until it stops. For an electric tank, switch off its breaker. For a gas tank, turn the control knob to off or to pilot. Then look at where the water is coming from. A drip from the pipe that runs down the side of the tank comes from the temperature and pressure relief valve, and the water from it can be scalding, so keep your hands clear. Water seeping from the tank body itself means the steel inside has rusted through, and that tank cannot be repaired.
If the leak keeps running after the cold valve is closed, shut the main valve where the water line enters the house and treat it as an emergency plumber call.
Why is there no hot water, or why does it run out so quickly?
With an electric tank, check its breaker once. If it trips again, leave it off: a shorted element or a failed thermostat is usually behind it, and the panels on the side of the tank cover live wiring. On a gas tank, a pilot that will not stay lit usually points to the thermocouple or flame sensor, or to a venting problem that the safety controls have picked up. You can try relighting it once, following the instructions on the tank label. If it goes out again, stop there.
Hot water that runs out faster than it used to is often a broken dip tube, a failed lower element, or a tank with so much mineral sediment in the bottom that there is less room for water. On a tankless unit the same problem shows up as an error code, or hot water that cuts out partway through a shower. Rusty water from the hot taps only, or hot water that smells of rotten eggs, usually traces back to the anode rod inside the tank.
What does Guelph's hard water do to a water heater?
The City of Guelph draws its tap water from the ground, and the City describes it as hard, with a lot of dissolved calcium and magnesium. Heat pushes those minerals out of the water. In a tank they settle on the bottom as scale, and that is the popping and rumbling you hear when the burner or the lower element comes on. In a tankless unit they coat the narrow passages of the heat exchanger until the water can no longer pass through freely.
Flushing a tank and descaling a tankless unit on a regular schedule slows this down. The City notes that water softeners and conditioners can change the effects of hard water. Softened water also changes how fast the anode rod wears, so on a softened supply the rod should be checked sooner. If you are fitting a tankless unit, ask for service valves on its water lines so that descaling is a simple job later on.
Outside the city the water is often harder still. The Township of Guelph/Eramosa publishes Rockwood's hardness as 570 mg/L as calcium carbonate, and the Town of Erin says its deep wells will calcify toilets and faucets. Homes in Puslinch, Aberfoyle and Morriston are on private wells, so the water a heater gets depends on the well. See Rockwood and Erin.
Is it worth repairing, or is it time to replace it?
Most faults outside the tank itself can be repaired: elements, thermostats, thermocouples, gas control valves, relief valves, dip tubes and anode rods. A tank that leaks from its body cannot. Anything in between is a judgement call. An older tank heavy with scale that needs its second or third repair in a short time may cost more to keep than to change.
Find the manufacture date on the label and check the manufacturer's warranty in your paperwork. Some warranties cover the tank for longer than the parts, and some expect the anode rod to have been checked along the way. The plumber shows you the part that failed. Where both repair and replacement make sense, you can ask for a price on each to compare, and the price for the work you choose is written down before work starts. Faults elsewhere in the house, such as a leaking valve or a corroded line, come under plumbing repairs.
How is a new water heater installed?
A new heater is sized to the household: how many people live there, how many bathrooms you have, whether there is a large tub, and whether a tankless unit can keep up with the flow in winter, when the incoming water is at its coldest. A gas heater needs proper venting and a sound gas line, and an electric one needs enough capacity at the panel.
Work is performed by licensed plumbers (306A Certificate of Qualification). Gas work is performed by TSSA-certified gas technicians. In Ontario, gas appliances such as water heaters come under Ontario Regulation 212/01 (Gaseous Fuels).
Ontario's Building Code (Article 7.2.10.7.) limits the water from a shower head or into a bathtub to 49 °C. Tanks are often set hotter than that, so a mixing valve or temperature-controlled fittings bring the water down before it reaches the fixtures. The City of Guelph building department decides whether a particular replacement needs a permit, so ask about it when you plan the job. When you are ready, request a quote and describe the heater you have now.
